What did The Giver advise the elders?

What did The Giver advise the elders?

The Giver explains to Jonas that he once advised the Committee of Elders against increasing the population. The Giver had memories of dramatic population booms, which led to starvation and warfare.

What advice does The Giver give to Jonas?

The Giver tells Jonas that his whole life will be nothing more than the memories he possesses. He occasionally will appear before the Committee of Elders to give them advice, but his primary function is to contain all the painful memories that the community cannot endure.

Why did The Giver advise the elders not to shoot down the plane?

He advised them not to shoot it down—as they wanted to—because he knew the horror that such hasty violence can cause. Jonas asks why everyone doesn’t have the memories, and The Giver explains that they don’t want everyone to have to be burdened with the suffering like the two of them are.

What reason does The Giver provide for why the elders decided to eliminate colors?

Jonas and the other community members are unable to see color because the community has eliminated colors in an effort to maintain sameness. Sameness is the community’s name for complete control over everyone’s lives. They want to ensure that everyone in the community shares the same experiences, as much as they can.

When did the elders ask the Giver for advice?

During one of their training sessions, the Giver explains to Jonas that on rare occasions the Committee of Elders calls upon him for advice when they are making a difficult decision in an area where they have no experience or wisdom. In chapter 14 , the Giver tells Jonas that…

Why did the Giver advise against increasing the population?

Once, the Elders were considering an increase in population because they wanted to have more Laborers. The Giver advised against it because he had memories of situations involving too many people and not enough food, and the people starved.

When did the elders ask The Giver for advice?

Why do elders rarely ask The Giver for advice?

Because the Committee of Elders seldom asks The Giver for advice, The Giver spends the majority of his time alone with his memories. The Giver advised against it because he had memories of situations involving too many people and not enough food, and the people starved.

Why do elders rarely ask the Giver for advice?

What did the giver advise the elders to do when they wanted to increase the population?

In chapter 14, the Giver tells Jonas that before he was born, the Committee of Elders wanted to increase the birth rate in order to have more Laborers. With more Laborers, the Committee of Elders wished to expand the community by assigning Birthmothers to have four children instead of three.

Why did the giver advise against increasing the population?

How did the giver help the Committee of elders?

In chapter 14, the Giver tells Jonas that before he was born, the Committee of Elders wanted to increase the birth rate in order to have more Laborers. With more Laborers, the Committee of Elders wished to expand the community by assigning Birthmothers to have four children instead of three.

Why do elders rarely ask the giver for advice?

However, the Elders rarely ask The Giver for advice, indicating that the static nature of the current society has replaced the values of wisdom and good judgment with those of obedience and maintaining the status quo.

How does the giver use his memories in the book?

For example, one year when the citizens petitioned for more births to increase the population of Laborers, The Giver used his memories to remember the starvation and warfare that resulted from overpopulation, although Jonas does not yet know war.

Why is Chapter 15 important in the giver?

Jonas’s decision to conceal the memory transmission from The Giver is also unusual, since it shows a new level of conscientious deception that he has never previously shown. Chapter 15 is a pivotal event in Jonas’s training as The Receiver because it introduces him to the concept of war, which drives home the terrible nature of a violent death.